The Girl, The Myth, The Fanfiction

Fanfiction as "Outsider"


As the previous section hinted at, simply defining fanfiction as derivative fiction misses the relationship it has with the realm of publishing and popular culture. If, as many will argue, fanfiction must be understood with its relation to copyrighted material, then fanfiction, almost by definition, is outside of the publishing world. This classification, though, doesn't hold up the way it used to. In the same vein, conversations surrounding the importance of community in fanfiction in Fanfiction as an Archive, can be misconstrued as portraying fanfiction writers and readers as a tight-knit community of "outsiders" choosing to engage with media differently than their peers. Neither of these characterizations are completely true nor false.  

In Textual Poachers, Henry Jenkins analyzes fans that produce their own work as engaging in an alternative mode of consumption of mainstream media. He explains that the way we are taught to engage with literature today requires us to engage in “passive [reception] of authorial meaning while any deviation from meanings clearly marked forth within the text is viewed negatively." Individual interpretation of literature is seen as either secondary or flat out wrong (Jenkins, 26, 2014). Jenkins and others of this era of fan studies, applaud fan writers for engaging with media differently, ignoring copyright laws and the fetish for authorial intention (Jenkins, 2014; Bacon-Smith, 6).

“The reader’s activity is no longer seen simply as the task of recovering the author’s meanings but also as reworking borrowed materials to fit them into the context of lived experience,”  Jenkins explains (51, 2013). Since the publication of Textual Poachers, many others have painted fan writers as, sort of, "outsiders," working against the original text to produce new, and often more radical, works. Camille Bacon-Smith commented not only on the transformative possibilities for fan writing, but also the gendered aspect of it in her book, Enterprising Women. Calling fan-writing "subversive," Bacon-Smith's book covers the community of female fan-writers who engage with media differently with the potential for radical or taboo topics.

Risk and community, for Bacon-Smith, are important components. Due to fanfiction’s relationship with copyright during that era, fan writing had to exist within tight knit communities in order to mitigate the risk of backlash from rights holders, (283-285). There is some truth in these portrayals, especially in the years preceding popular use of the internet. In fact, rights holders for popular franchises such as LucasFilms did attempt, in the 80s, to moderate and control fan writing. While the Star Wars franchise typically left fan writers who wrote family-friendly fanfiction alone, cease-and-desist letters were sent to fan writers who produced more risqué content (Jamison,103-104). Even during the early years of the internet, many fanfiction sites did not allow homosexual pairings or required that they all be rated R or M for mature audiences (Tandy, 171-174). The situation today, however, is much more open.

"With the rise of personal computing in the 1980s and of the internet in the 1990s, fanfiction increasingly has been electronically produced and digitally distributed. The effects of this shift on the community, the literature it produces, and the brought reading and writing public are really only beginning to be understood... In addition to speed, the internet brought anonymity. No more mailing addresses or phone numbers were needed to receive fandom news. At first, emails and IDs (anonymous or pseudonyms) sufficed, and then fanboards sprang up- many requiring no registration. Fanfiction became free, open, public” (Jamison, 112).

 

The paradox of fanfiction is that it appears "outsider" while continuing to occupy a fairly large space in popular culture. Due to the anonymity provided by the internet, individuals who would never dare step onto a convention floor can still enjoy a good fic in the privacy of their own home. While being a "fan...still remains culturally stigmatized," more people can engage in fannish behaviors without any social implications (LaChev, 85). Shows that have particularly strong fan-bases even reference fanfiction in interviews or at conventions, (Hellekson & Busse, 4; Jamison,132). Instead of actually being a fringe activity, fanfiction seems to have become many people's "dirty little secret," with most people (including those who have never read a fanfiction) able to identify what it is (Hellekson & Busse, 4).

Further, the seemingly integral aspect of fanfiction as unpublished material is breaking apart. Few fan studies papers today don't include at least a passing mention of 50 Shades of Grey. Once a Twilight fanfiction named "Master of the Universe" written under the pen-name of Snowqueens Icedragon, 50 Shades of Grey has demonstrated just how far fanfiction has come (Hellekson & Busse, 5; Jamison, 224-252; Coppa, 11). Fanfiction can be just as popular, if not more, than the story it was based on. But, we knew that already... how many kids have seen The Lion King without ever having read Hamlet?

This page has paths:

This page references: